News
BREAKING: Appeal court affirms El-Rufai’s right to fair hearing
The Court of Appeal has upheld the right of Nasir El-Rufai to a fair hearing, overturning the earlier decision delivered by Justice R.M. Aikawa of the Federal High Court in Kaduna.
The appellate court gave the ruling while deciding an appeal filed by El-Rufai against the Kaduna State House of Assembly, marked CA/K/240/2024.
Details of the judgment were made public on Tuesday by El-Rufai’s media adviser, Muyiwa Adekeye.
The appellate court held that the Federal High Court erred by proceeding with the hearing on 18th July 2024 without properly serving El-Rufai with notice and denying him the opportunity to respond to the respondents’ counter-affidavit.
As a result, the Court of Appeal nullified the proceedings of 18th July 2024 and set aside the judgment delivered on 30th July 2024 for lack of jurisdiction.
The matter has been remitted to the Federal High Court for reassignment to a different judge to hear the case afresh.
El-Rufai had filed a fundamental rights enforcement suit in 2024, challenging the Kaduna State House of Assembly over alleged denial of a fair hearing during its investigations.
The trial court had initially adjourned the matter but later proceeded in his absence, granting respondents’ applications and denying him the chance to respond.
In his appeal, El-Rufai, through his lawyer, AU Mustapha SAN, argued that the matter was improperly heard during vacation without any application and that the trial judge refused to recuse himself.
The Court of Appeal focused on two issues: (i) proper service of the hearing notice, and (ii) the denial of the opportunity to file a further affidavit.
On service, the court emphasised that only the contact details provided by parties are valid for notice, and there was no evidence that El-Rufai was served.
On the second issue, the court held that under the Fundamental Rights (Enforcement Procedure) Rules, El-Rufai was entitled to file a further affidavit and reply on points of law within five days, and the trial court had no discretion to deny this.
The judgment reinforces the judiciary’s commitment to fair hearing and proper procedure, particularly in matters affecting fundamental rights.
Follow Us on Google Discover
Mbappé makes history, Saka nets hat-trick as England clinch World Cup bronze with thrilling 6-4 victory over France
Gombe 2027: PDP aspirant withdraws court case, backs Pantami
Arabic Education should be integrated into national curriculum – Gov. Bala Mohammed
Obi/Kwankwaso ticket cannot win 2027 elections, NDC lone senator, Hanga says as he plots defection to APC
UNICAL moves to curb exam fraud, sacks eight staff, penalizes one
TCN announces power blackout in Yobe, Bauchi, Gombe, three other Northern states
Police nab eight suspected cultists over alleged assault on Bayelsa Varsity student
Tems makes history as first African female artist with US Diamond-certified single
Imo now one-party state, our people have decided to re-elect Tinubu in 2027, Says Uzodimma
Court sentences two men to death by hanging for raping, murdering 17-year-old girl in Anambra
Trump criticises Tuchel’s tactics after England’s World Cup exit to Argentina
NBA Presidential Poll: Badejo-Okusanya leads as voting continues after cyberattack delay
APC crisis deepens as Aiyedatiwa’s loyalists sue party, INEC over Ondo primaries
NUJ FCT Chairman Grace Ike wins Beacon of Education Award, pledges support for children with special needs
5.0-magnitude quake rocks Southeastern Turkey
8 Public assets named after Tinubu since becoming president (Full List)
JUST IN: Three face trial over Oyo schoolchildren, teachers’ abduction
TCN announces power blackout in Yobe, Bauchi, Gombe, three other Northern states
Ex-President Goodluck Jonathan’s son bags degree in UK
APC crisis deepens as Aiyedatiwa’s loyalists sue party, INEC over Ondo primaries
Supreme Court directs final forfeiture of Emefiele’s properties
Court sentences two men to death by hanging for raping, murdering 17-year-old girl in Anambra
FG renames Lagos-Calabar Coastal Highway after President Tinubu
Yobe approves ₦460.8m support for Akara sellers, Women petty traders
Bauchi 2027: APC picks ex-Bala Mohammed campaign DG Faruk Mustapha as Deputy Gov candidate
Imo now one-party state, our people have decided to re-elect Tinubu in 2027, Says Uzodimma
BREAKING: Andy Burnham confirmed as UK Labour leader
It’s too early to judge Tinubu’s gov’t, Nigerians must be patient – Jide Kosoko
Court dismisses suit seeking INEC recognition of Turaki-led PDP interim NWC
